Tuesday, 17 May 2016

An Everyday Linux User Review Of Ubuntu 16.04 - The Good, The Bad And The Not Quite So Ugly

Posted by Gary Newell  |  at  22:26 16 comments

Introduction



Last month saw the release of everybody's favourite Linux distribution, Ubuntu. I have spent the past couple of weeks reading other people's opinions, watching videos and listening to podcasts.

I have also spent some time trying out the latest offering and within this review I will highlight the new features, the bits I like, the bits I think are a little bit strange and the things I really don't like at all.

New Features For Ubuntu 16.04

Some people aren't interesting in reading a full review so I will list the new features here so that you can go about your day should you feel the need.


I am approaching the new features from the point of view of a standard desktop user as that is what Everyday Linux User is about.

Snap Packages

Ubuntu has introduced a new kind of package called snap. You might be thinking "wow that is just what we need, another package format". Actually in this case it is a really good idea.

Snap packages are installed as sandboxed software (much like Android apps) which means that they won't interfere with other parts of your system. This is more secure than standard package formats and the software won't be bothered by missing libraries and conflicts.

To find the new snap packages you need to open a terminal window.

You can search for snap packages using the following command:

snap find
This provides a list of packages. You can install a package using the following command:

snap install packagename
Unfortunately when I run these commands however I get the following error:
download snap "ubuntu-core" from channel "stable" (snap not found)
The number of snap packages available is currently very small but as a feature I suspect this is one for the future and one to look out for. Meanwhile if anyone wants to tell me why I am getting this error I would be truly grateful.

Linux Kernel 4.4

If you own a modern computer the 4.4 kernel released with Ubuntu 16.04 is a godsend. This prevents me having to perform so many tricks such as backporting in order to get wireless working on my Lenovo Ideapad Y700.

That isn't to say that the wireless problems go away completely. On the Ideapad there is still an issue which I will come to later on.

Python 3

This probably won't matter to the average user but if you dabble in Python development you should know that only Python 3 is installed by default and therefore your programs written for Python 2 will not work unless you install Python 2.

Gnome Software Replaces The Ubuntu Software Centre

Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes.

In my review of Ubuntu 15.10 my comments with regards to the Ubuntu Software Centre were as follows:

"the main application for installing software in Ubuntu is the Software Centre and I think it has to be the biggest drawback for new users. 
Let's take the three applications listed in the previous section, Skype, DropBox and Steam. 
Each one of these applications is less straight forward to install than it should be using the Software Centre.
The answer by the Ubuntu developers is to remove it completely and use the Gnome Software manager instead.

This isn't to say that all the problems have been solved but it shows that the developers do listen.

Online Searches Disabled By Default

One of the least popular features added to Ubuntu in recent years was the inclusion of online searches within the Dash.

This has now been switched off by default although you can turn it back on if you so wish.

Other

Here are the rest of the announced amendments:

  • Gnome calendar included by default
  • Brasero and Empathy removed from the default installation (DVD burner and chat client)
  • Chromium is now version 48 and Firefox is at version 45
  • More supported languages
  • Bug fixes
  • Various Compiz and Unity amendments
  • LibreOffice is now at 5.1

How To Get Ubuntu 16.04

You can download Ubuntu 16.04 from http://www.ubuntu.com/download/desktop






Simply click the download button.

Note that by default you will get the 64-bit version. If you want a 32-bit version you will need to click the "alternative downloads and torrents link".

I am guessing that if you are using a 32-bit computer it is quite old and therefore might not be up to running Ubuntu 16.04.


You will be taken to a donation page where you can choose how much to pay for Ubuntu. There is a link in the bottom left corner which allows you to download it for free.


How To Create A Ubuntu USB Drive

If you want to create your own Ubuntu USB drive download Ubuntu and follow this guide.

How To Install Ubuntu

To dual boot Ubuntu and Windows 10 follow one of these guides:


Changes To The Installer

The Ubuntu installer has changed subtly since Ubuntu 15.10. 



















The pre-requisites screen has gone and there is also no longer a screen which asks you to connect to a wireless network.

After choosing your language you will see the above screen which gives you the option to download updates and to install third party software.

Note that the download updates is greyed out. This is only available if you connect to the internet.

For those of you wanting to take advantage of this feature connect to the internet before running the installer.






















You can connect to the internet by clicking on the network icon in the top right corner and by choosing your wireless network of choice. If you connect using a wired connection you won't have to do this.

The pre-requisites screen was largely pointless and so I am not surprised that it is gone. It used to have three options:

  • are you connected to the internet
  • are you connected to a power source
  • have you got 6 gigabytes of hard disk space
You didn't need to be connected to the internet to install Ubuntu and you didn't really need to be connected to a power source if you have enough battery left on a laptop and if you are using a desktop computer why wouldn't you be connected to a power source.

The minimum disk space requirement was also incredibly small and gave the false impression that you could get away with such a low amount. 

The decision to remove the network connection screen in the installer is probably a bit more strange. I would at least expect a link giving the option to connect to the internet so you could download updates if you want to.

Not really a deal breaker though.

First Impressions






















For the average user not much appears to have changed from previous versions of Ubuntu and I want to talk about this because I have watched this video which has a mini rant about Ubuntu and this one from what used to be the Linux Help Guy but who is now the Windows Help Guy.

The general upshot is that Ubuntu has become boring. The complaint is that nothing has changed in a few years. 

I watch most of the videos by VWestlife because he does produce interest and detailed reviews about old hardware and technology. He has never really been a Linux fan though.

I liken the "Ubuntu has become boring" thing with an old episode of the BBC sitcom "Fawlty Towers" whereby a lady complains about the view from a hotel window. 

The transcript from Fawlty Towers goes something like this:

  • Customer: "when i pay for a view I expect something more interesting than that"
  • Basil Fawlty (Owner): "but that is Torquay madam"
  • Customer: "well it is not good enough"
  • Basil: "well may I ask what you expected to see out a Torquay hotel window? Sydney Opera House perhaps? The Hanging Gardens Of Babylon? Herds of wilderbeest sweeping across the plain
The point is this. Ubuntu is now far more stable than it has ever been. There is no need to make massive changes to the user interface. They did that already 5 years ago and got seriously panned for doing so.

The changes over the past few years have been measured and one thing I really have to compliment the developers on is their ability to listen.

For instance when Unity was first released the menu bars were stuck at the top and there was no way of moving them. People complained and an option was put in to choose where to place the menus.

People complained about the shopping results and online results in the Dash. Options were put in to remove them or show them based on a setting.

Users complained about the Ubuntu Software Centre and the developers have done something about it.

Users wanted to be able to place the launcher at the bottom of the screen and the developers have implemented the ability to do so, although it is a terminal command:

Ubuntu is rock steady. Yes there are bugs and yes there are inconsistencies but there are bugs and inconsistencies with all operating systems including Windows 10.

A lot of the work with Ubuntu is going on behind the scenes, getting ready for a move to MIR and the introduction of snap packages. These just don't happen overnight.

All in all Ubuntu is much like it has been for the past few years. There is a panel at the top and a launcher down the left.

There are a whole host of keyboard shortcuts which can be used to manage the system.

Finally there is a dash interface for finding and launching applications.


As mentioned previously you can connect to the internet by clicking on the network icon in the top right corner.

Simply choose the network you wish to connect to and enter the security key.





Installing Software























The Ubuntu Software Centre has been replaced by the GNOME Software manager. 

The main screen highlights featured applications, editor's picks, recommended applications from a particular category (i.e. sometimes it will be graphics, other times audio etc) and finally a list of categories.



Clicking on a category pulls up a list of sub categories. The right panel will show the items within the sub category. By default you see the featured items within the category.

From the main screen you can also search for a package by name or description.


 All good thus far. I did however find some issues with the new package manager.

The package manager doesn't list anything that requires a command line. That means tools such as the youtube downloader don't appear.



























You can however install the Youtube Browser for SMPlayer which does allow you to download Youtube videos.

Slightly more worrying is the fact you can't install Steam.
























Another thing that doesn't appear are the restricted extras packages.



























Whilst you can install the third party codecs using the installer many people don't and many people use the restricted extras packages. (myself included).

The first program I recommend installing via the software manager is Synaptic.























A quick search in Synaptic for restricted extras brings up a complete list of packages.

A bug that appeared in the previous couple Ubuntu releases was that installing the restricted extras package via Synaptic or any other graphical tool failed because of a license agreement that didn't appear.


This bug has been fixed which means you can install the entire package using Synaptic.

I find it a little bit ironic that this bug has been there for at least 2 releases and now the bug has been fixed you can't find the software in the default graphical package manager.

Another package that can't be found in the Software Manager is Chrome. You can find Chromium but not Chrome. Like many other people I think Chrome is the only worthy web browser as it includes all the features that are required from a browser including the ability to play Flash videos and games.



In order to install Chrome I went to the Google website and clicked on the "Download" link.  An option appears for 64-bit Ubuntu/Debian. When you choose this option you can choose to save the file or open it.

Choosing the save option saves the file to your downloads folder. Clicking on the downloaded file opens up the installer in the Gnome Software Manager.

You would think it was plain sailing from this point on. Click "Install" and away you go. Unfortunately it doesn't work.

Back to the command line I am afraid. Open a terminal using CTRL, ALT and T and then type the following:

cd ~/Downloadssudo dpkg -i google-chrome-stable_current_amd64.deb

It will fail to install.

Now run this command:

sudo apt-get install -f


Finally run this command again:


sudo dpkg -i google-chrome-stable_current_amd64.deb
It finally installs.





When it comes to installing Steam even Synaptic didn't help.

It was purely command line:

sudo apt-get install steam
 A license agreement will appear. Click tab to select the ok button and return to accept it.

Another screen will be displayed with the option to accept or decline the agreement. Use the tab key to select "I Agree". Then tab to "OK" and press return.

All in all the Software Centre may have gone but the pain lives on and in many ways the situation feels much worse than it was in Ubuntu 15.10. I think these issues need to be dealt ASAP.

Audio












The default audio player in Ubuntu 16.04 is Rhythmbox (and it has been for some time). It is probably one of the best Linux applications available and far surpasses anything provided by other proprietary operating systems.

Click here for a complete guide to Rhythmbox

LibreOffice

LibreOffice is the premier free office suite for Linux and for the average home user it has everything you need.

With a word processing packages, spreadsheet package, presentation package and drawing package you can easily write letters, books, produce budgets and create presentations.

It may not be Microsoft Office but for most people it actually has more than enough features. It is perfect for students.

Thunderbird





























The email client in Ubuntu 16.04 is Thunderbird. Personally I prefer Evolution but Thunderbird can easily be set up to work with common mail providers such as Google's GMail.

Video























The default video player is Totem.

You can choose to watch local video files or you can choose the search feature. There are a couple of default channels or you can choose to search various other channels such as Youtube.

Other Software

There are lots of packages installed by default so I won't list them all but here are the highlights:

  • Rhythmbox - Audio 
  • Totem - Video
  • Thunderbird - Email
  • Firefox - Web Browser
  • Shotwell - Photo Manager
  • Cheese - Webcam Viewer
  • LibreOffice - Office Suite
  • Transmission - Bittorrent Client
  • Gnome Calendar - Calendar

Hardware Support

This is a bit of a mixed report. Everything works fine on my existing Dell and Toshiba laptops.

I can connect to the Epson WF2630 printer. The scanner and printer work well.

I can also connect to a Western Digital MyCloud device.

My new Lenovo Y700 Ideapad had a few extra issues however. The Intel Wireless Network card needed some extra steps to get it working. 

The NVidia graphics card was picked up but then I was locked out at the login screen. I fixed the issue (which I will write about in another post) but it wasn't plain sailing.

Performance

On my Dell Inspiron 3521 is a little bit sluggish when using the Gnome package manager. The Lenovo Ideapad however runs like a dream and Ubuntu is the perfect operating system for it.

It doesn't take a rocket scientist to suggest that better hardware provides better performance.

Moving The Launcher



You can now move the launcher to the bottom of the screen.

To do so open a terminal window and enter the following command:

gsettings set com.canonical.Unity.Launcher launcher-position Bottom

To set it back to the left side use the following command:


gsettings set com.canonical.Unity.Launcher launcher-position Left

If you were hoping to put it on the right side then you will have to wait a bit longer for that.

Issues

For a long term support release I have come across lots of issues, most of which have been already covered.

The latest NVidia cards will probably get you into a loop at the login screen unless you use the Nouveau driver.

The latest Intel wireless cards don't work straight away.

The new software manager tool doesn't install Chrome, Steam or anything that requires the command line.

Summary

To summarise I want to go back to the title:

The Good

The developers do appear to listen to their users. Everything that people have asked for in the past few years has been implemented in one way or another.

The Bad

This is a long term support release and it feels like it isn't quite ready. I find it hard to believe that nobody working on Ubuntu tried a clean install, followed by installing some of the more popular applications like Chrome, Dropbox and Steam.

The Not Quite So Ugly

The Software Centre has gone.

This would have been great as a point release, say a 16.10 or a 17.04 because you expect some experimentation and you expect the odd cock-up.

The LTS release should be ready to go from day one with only minor issues. Sadly that isn't the case.

About the Author

Gary Newell started the Everyday Linux User blog in 2010 and has written reviews on dozens of different Linux based operating systems. He has also written a number of tutorials.

Get Updates

Subscribe to our e-mail newsletter to receive updates.

Share This Post

Related posts

16 comments:

  1. When I install a .deb package I always install gdebi app. It takes care of any issues. I use it with "cd Downloads [enter]
    Sudo gdebi google*[enter]".

    ReplyDelete
  2. A balanced review. I feel that as the number of users of Linux (including Ubuntu) as a desktop OS increases, the developers will listen more and the number of applications will also increase. Closed source OS and application makers get enough licencing fees to improve their software. For Linux/ open source developers this route is not open, I think and other models of revenue generation will have to be used.

    ReplyDelete
  3. For me the best Ubuntu experience is using the Mate desktop. It might be helpful if you would compare and contrast Ubuntu Desktops. Also adding Ubuntu PPA's, how and what is safe. I add Web8 PPA's to my repository. I do realize there can be security issues with some PPA's. Which do you recommend as safe?

    ReplyDelete
  4. The number of desktop Linux users WON'T increase if this is representative of one of the top distros. A long term release that "feels like it isn't quite ready?" Can't install Chrome without jumping through hoops. You have to go to the terminal to move a GUI item to a different location on the screen? Ability to connect to wireless on a modern laptop is seen as a breakthrough? I've been trying to leave Windows for years, but every time I do, I quickly run into something Linux can't or won't do that Windows does easily. When someone releases a Linux distro that just plain works, I'll be on board.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Let's just hope these get ironed out for the next release, or at least the next release of Linux Mint. Then again, fiddling with firmware just to get laptop wifi working was so 2005.

    ReplyDelete
  6. The connecting to the Internet screen was removed (I didn't even notice that it was gone since I wasn't using it anyway, good spot!) because it didn't work, lol. Instead of fixing the bug in the installer it seems like they just removed the feature and effectively force you to figure out that you need to connect to the Internet via the indicator. Not ideal, but that's probably because Ubiquity is a program made by Ubuntu (not an upstream program) and so just removing the feature means they can spend more time getting Ubuntu Next (Unity 8) sorted out.

    ReplyDelete
  7. And yes, there are a lot of bugs in Ubuntu atm, it's partially because not enough people are testing the development release and partially because Canonical are busy working on Ubuntu Next so I think Ubuntu current is largely being maintained by volunteer developers at the moment (like most other distributions!) This article seems really helpful though because you run into so many bugs, it should all 'just work', have you filed bugs for each of the issues with `ubuntu-bug package_name` or at least marked yourself as affected by the various bugs on Launchpad? It would be very helpful if you did that!

    ReplyDelete
  8. I've been using Ubuntu 16.04 for several weeks and so far it's been just a treat. Usually Mint is my defacto linux distro but after giving this iteration of Ubuntu a try I'm hooked.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Gnome Software: "Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes." That's the most noticeable change of any kind for me thus far, and I'm in full agreement with your enthusiasm about it (though I'll still use Synaptic or Aptitude as needed, because sometimes they're just more natural for me).

    Unlike you, Gary, I did not do a clean install. I updated on July 18 from 14.04LTS on an aging 32-bit Dell Latitude XT2, and this has been the cleanest and easiest upgrade experience for me in something like 40 years, (one or two Mac upgrades have been close contenders).

    The XT2 was designed with "multitouch" input that was managed by software never perfected by Dell in Windows (one result: the cursor might suddenly start bouncing around the screen and opening programs randomly until the OS was in a useless state). So this notebook of mine never got much use with Windows, and the 2014 install of Ubuntu was a welcome relief.

    I was able to tame the cursor without much trouble using xinput in Ubuntu 14.04, and in 16.06 I find that I don't need any of the old workarounds. That's a real plus for users of such older hardware, and another reason I appreciate the open source developers who continue chasing these bugs until they're gone.

    A final point: Though I don't have a lot of data stored on this computer, I do have a lot of software installed for web development, graphics, sound editing and general nerdishness: Emacs, the Eclipse IDE, Bluefish, Meld, Geany, Sublime Text, GiMP, Inkscape, Audacity, an Apache web server, MySQL ... and a lot more that you might question running on an older box. I try things out and keep them for occasional use until I find reasons to dump them. I run a few older Windows executables in Wine, and one old DOS text editor (XyWrite) in DosBox. With all of that junk installed, and all of it purring along nicely without conflicts, the 160GB hard drive in this funky old notebook is actually using about 16GB of drive space. So when I speak of what's lacking in Ubuntu, now or in the future, I'll always be happy to add that one of the best things lacking is code bloat.

    ReplyDelete
  10. the review is nice as the others, but I have to point out that I had no problems whatsoever in installing chrome from the .deb package downloaded its site on my sony vaio (clean install from live CD bought with a magazine)

    ReplyDelete
  11. Nice review as always, but I have to point out that I had no problem whatsoever in installing Chrome from the .deb package on my Sony Vaio (clean install from a live CD bought with a magazine)

    ReplyDelete
  12. ubuntu 16.04 sometimes hanging problem how to resolve, after restart the system. many times this problem comes please help me, my id sahokkumar0707@gmail.com any sajasan please send me, thanku

    ReplyDelete
  13. I just started reading your articles today after the million billionth problem with Windows 10 which I now have to buy every year. Your 'bad' sounds pretty good to this windows stress victim. Very best regards!

    ReplyDelete
  14. Installing even Ubuntu is like putting a puzzle together. You don't always get all the pieces together. Your left with one nagging problem or hardware issue that just frustrates. It's probably why most average laymen PC users pass on using Linux or even trying it. The advantages are there once you get past the install. But many who are used to a more supported system like Windows that just installs and updates drivers and has full support of PC makers is just easier. I certainly don't love Windows 10 by any stretch, but I can install it and it works and works well which is a big plus in my life using a PC.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Just a update, Ubuntu 16.10 fixes a lot with newer hardware. I did notice the TouchPad scrolls too fast now in Firefox? You know
      I'm just not a fan of this flat bland GUI that Windows and Ubuntu have. I's pretty sad when Mac OS looks better than both Windows 10 and Ubuntu.

      Delete

Feel free to comment on any of the blog posts. Please try to be constructive.

Offensive messages will be removed as will blatant adverts for misleading products and sites.

Thanks for visiting my blog

    Popular Posts

    Total Pageviews

    Subscribe

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

    Popular This Month

    What are other people buying?

    Ubuntu Buy
    openSUSE Buy
    Manjaro Buy
    Zorin Buy
    PCLinuxOS Buy
    gNewSense Buy
    Edubuntu Buy
    Fedora Buy
    Uberstudent Buy
    Linux Lite Buy
    Lubuntu Buy
    Xubuntu Buy

    Followers

    Feedburner Followers

Blogger templates. Proudly Powered by Blogger.


back to top Google